Best Buffets in New Ulm, Minnesota (2026)

We compared 2 buffets in New Ulm, Minnesota using customer ratings and review counts. Top pick: Pizza Ranch (4.3 from 734 reviews).

Pizza Ranch

📍 1927 S Broadway St, New Ulm, MN 56073

4.3 (734 reviews)

American Buffet Pizza Buffet

Prices & hours → 📞

The Restaurant on The Hill

📍 1955 Luther Ct, New Ulm, MN 56073

1.0 (1 reviews)

Prices & hours →

Ranked by customer rating weighted by number of reviews. Permanently closed buffets are excluded. See all buffets in New Ulm →

Best Buffets in New Ulm: FAQ

What is the best buffet in New Ulm, Minnesota?

Based on ratings and review counts in our directory, Pizza Ranch ranks first among 2 buffets in New Ulm, Minnesota, with a 4.3 rating from 734 reviews. The Restaurant on The Hill is second.

How many buffets are there in New Ulm, Minnesota?

Our directory lists 2 buffets in New Ulm, Minnesota.

Which buffet in New Ulm, Minnesota has the most reviews?

Pizza Ranch has the most reviews of the listings we track here, with 734 reviews and a 4.3 rating.

How are these buffets ranked?

Listings are ranked by a weighted average of their customer rating and number of reviews, so a place with a few perfect reviews does not outrank one with hundreds of strong reviews. Permanently closed buffets are left out, and listings without ratings appear after rated ones. Rankings update automatically as the directory changes.