Best Seafood Buffets in Brooklyn, New York (2026)

We compared 3 seafood buffets in Brooklyn, New York using customer ratings and review counts. Top pick: Flaming Grill & Buffet (4.3 from 1,347 reviews).

Ranked by customer rating weighted by number of reviews. Permanently closed buffets are excluded. See all buffets in Brooklyn →

What to expect at a seafood buffet

Seafood buffets put crab legs, shrimp, crawfish, mussels, oysters and fried fish at the center of the line. Many Chinese buffets also run a "seafood buffet" at dinner and on weekends. Prices are higher than standard buffets and often change with the market price of crab. Read the full guide →

Best Seafood Buffets in Brooklyn: FAQ

What is the best seafood buffet in Brooklyn, New York?

Based on ratings and review counts in our directory, Flaming Grill & Buffet ranks first among 3 seafood buffets in Brooklyn, New York, with a 4.3 rating from 1,347 reviews. Umi Premium Sushi & Seafood Buffet is second and Seaport Buffet is third.

How many seafood buffets are there in Brooklyn, New York?

Our directory lists 3 seafood buffets in Brooklyn, New York.

Which seafood buffet in Brooklyn, New York has the most reviews?

Umi Premium Sushi & Seafood Buffet has the most reviews of the listings we track here, with 3,078 reviews and a 4.1 rating.

How are these buffets ranked?

Listings are ranked by a weighted average of their customer rating and number of reviews, so a place with a few perfect reviews does not outrank one with hundreds of strong reviews. Permanently closed buffets are left out, and listings without ratings appear after rated ones. Rankings update automatically as the directory changes.